Why Talk Therapy Sometimes Stops Working for Trauma

Are you a therapy warrior? If you’ve been in talk therapy before (or have been for years) you probably already understand yourself pretty well.

You know why certain things trigger you.
You can explain where your patterns come from.
You’ve talked through your past more than once (and likely with more than one person).
But it feels like the changes you want to make aren’t sticking.

You still feel triggered, overwhelmed, anxious, emotionally overloaded, or shut down, even when you know you’re safe. You might think to yourself:

“I’ve talked about this for years. Why doesn’t it feel better?”

If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone.

‍

When Talk Therapy Helps and When It Starts to Feel Stuck

Talk therapy can be incredibly helpful. It often supports people in:

• Understanding their emotions and why they’re there
• Making sense of past experiences and their impact on you
• Identifying patterns in new (and old) relationships
• Learning coping strategies that work great in the therapy office
• Feeling seen and heard
  
  

For many people, this kind of insight is life-changing.
But for someone who has lived through trauma, results may vary…

You may gain awareness, but not relief.
You may understand your triggers, but still feel like you can’t control your response to them.
You may feel frustrated that you’ve done the work, and your day to day isn’t shifting.

This doesn’t mean talk therapy “didn’t work.”

It means your brain and nervous system are wired to respond to something regardless of what you logically know is not a threat. It means, you may need to learn a new language to help your body understand you are safe now. Talking and thinking alone can’t always translate the message, and that’s when it’s time to switch things up!

‍

Why Understanding Trauma Doesn’t Always Stop the Reactions

Trauma isn’t just a story you remember. It’s an experience your nervous system learned.

When something overwhelming happens (especially repeatedly or without enough support) the brain stores that experience in survival mode. This part of the brain is fast, automatic, and protective.

That’s why:

• You feel stress/anxiety in your body before you can think.
• Your body reacts even when you know that logically you are safe.
• You feel like you have no choice in how your body reacts (no matter how many times you’re faced with a trigger).
  
  

These automatic reactions have nothing to do with willpower or whether or not you have talked about these triggers in talk therapy.

It’s your survival instincts kicking in from when it was wired to protect you the very first time it needed to.

Your brain doesn’t need to be understood cognitively, your nervous system needs a reset.

‍

Why Talking About Trauma Can Reach a Ceiling

Talk therapy primarily works from the “top-down”  (through insight, reasoning, and mindful awareness, and planning intentional behavior changes).

Trauma responses, however, live “bottom-up”  (in the nervous system, body sensations, and reactive emotional memory that triggers a flight/fight/freeze response).

So even if you can talk through your traumatic experience while in your “thinking brain,” when a trigger occurs, your nervous system and “emotional brain” may still be reacting as if the danger is happening now.

This is why people often say:

• “I know I’m safe, I don’t know why I keep freaking out.”
• “I had a plan to change my habit, but when I’m stressed, I can’t seem to stop myself.”
• “Talking helps, but it hasn’t changed my reactions.”
  
  

If that’s your experience, you’re not doing therapy wrong.
Your brain may just need a different approach to continue healing.

‍

When Therapy Needs to Shift (Not Start Over)

Reaching a plateau in therapy can feel discouraging. Some people worry they are:

• Too broken
• Doing therapy incorrectly
• Lacking willpower
  
  

In reality, many people don’t need more insight, they need a different type of intervention. One that rewires the brain AND the nervous system.

This is where therapies like EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) can be helpful.

In the next entry, we’ll explore how trauma gets stored in the  body — and why logic alone doesn’t always work to respond the way we thought we would after the last talk therapy session!

‍

Main Take-Away?

If you’ve gained insight but still feel stuck it doesn’t mean therapy failed you.
It means your nervous system may be asking for a different kind of support.
And that’s not a weakness. That’s a sign you’re paying attention.
That’s a sign that hope is there for the next step in your healing journey.

You deserve care that supports both your mind and your nervous system. Reach out to me for a chat, or stay tuned as I add more entries and resources to my website and social media!

‍